On 23rd April 1999, the Malaysian government together with other ASEAN governments signed THE BANGKOK DECLARATION ON IRREGULAR MIGRATION, and declaration 14 states as follows:-
Irregular migrants should be granted humanitarian treatment, including appropriate health and other services, while the cases of irregular migration are being handled according to law. Any unfair treatment towards them should be avoided;
Health services was specifically mentioned. We recall that it was reported in the media in December 2008, that "About 1,300 illegal foreigners have died during detention in the past six years, Malaysia Nanban quoted Malaysian Human Rights (Suhakam) commissioner Datuk N. Siva Subramaniam as saying. He said many of them died in immigration detention centres, prisons and police lockups because they were denied medical treatment at the right time.” [Star, 18/12/2008, ‘1,300 foreign detainees died due to neglect’] This was again reiterated ABC News(28/5/2009) Malaysia detention centres 'violating rights' .The Bar Council tells us that, "...The Dewan Rakyat figure would mean that an average of one migrant dies in custody almost every day!" - Bar Council: Deaths of migrants in prisons, rehabilitation and detention centres
Finally, the government tells us that it is because migrants eat grass...and walk around barefooted..Are they not provided footware?
The detention centers are an enclosed environment, it is not a village where animals may be freely moving around....or dying. Hygine of all detention places, especially within the fences, should be kept hygienic, clean and disease free. And why are detainees eating grass ...are they not been sufficiently fed? Are they being starved...that they are force to eat grass?
Leptospirosis, a communicable disease, has been linked to environmental contamination in Malaysian detention centres, where eight deaths have been recorded this year.
Dr Anis Salwa Kamarudin of the Health Ministry's public health division said the cases are linked to certain habits of detainees, such as eating grass and walking around barefooted.
“Some of these detainees like to eat grass which grows in the camp (compound),” she said in a written response on how the disease spreads and what measures are being taken to prevent the incidence of communicable diseases in immigration detention centres.
In May, two detainees died of leptospirosis at the Juru immigration detention centre, while six more succumbed in August at the KLIA immigration detention depot.
Anis explained that infection occurs either directly through contact with urine or tissues of animal carcasses, or indirectly through the contaminated environment soil, water, drainage and plants.
This includes consumption of contaminated food and water, as well as breathing air with the leptospira bacteria.
The spread of infectious diseases in detention centres is also due to overcrowding and poor hygiene, Anis said.
"Diseases spread easily where the population density is high - scabies, impetigo, tuberculosis, pneumonia and influenza are among the communicable diseases," she said.
Diarrhoea, enterovirus, hand, mouth and foot disease, salmonella, Hepatitis A and polio are spread through contaminated faeces, while Hepatitis B and C, HIV/Aids and cytomegalovirus are caused by contamination of the blood.
Anis said the ministry has taken several measures to ensure the health and safety of the detainees, to control leptospirosis among other diseases.
These include annual inspection of cleanliness of living quarters, water supply, and areas where food is handled, prepared and served.
Medical services are extended to immigration detention centres every fortnight, with referrals to hospitals when required.
'More needs to be done'
Tenaganita director Florida Sandanasamy said, however, that much more can and should be done to improve the health of detainees.
She questioned the quality and adequacy of food and water supplies, pointing out that no one will resort to eating grass unless they are desperate.
Detention centres should have an in-house doctor to provide immediate medical attention, she said.
"When detainees complain of sickness, they are often not taken seriously and have to repeatedly ask for treatment. Sometimes, when their condition worsens and they are rushed to the hospital, it is too late.
"The government should also have better planning in space allocation, as it is a known fact that densely populated areas attract all kind of diseases.”
Florida also pointed to dirty toilets and the lack of proper bedding - or filthy, bug-infested items - as other sources of problems.
“In fact, the detainees are not given a change of clothes, sometimes having to wear the same clothing until they are released," she claimed.
She also called for attention to the mental health and overall well being of detainees, as this has been neglected by the government.
"The detainees suffer from trauma and abuse, and are very prone to depression," she added.- Malaysiakini, 14/12/2009, When detainees turn grass-eaters...
Not including medical cost, the government says that a sum of RM30 is spent per migrant per day...and, this is surely to provide good balanced diet, clean food trays, bedding, clothes and slippers... RM30 works out RM900 per month, and this is more than what most workers earn monthly...
First, it was the Immigration Department who ran these Detention Centres, but they did not do a good job, and the government transferred the responsibility to the experts, the Prison Department. Then, for no reason this responsibility was given to RELA...and, maybe it has now been handed back to the Immigration Department...or is still under RELA?
Rela members will be trained to take over the full-time running of the country's 14 immigration depots by the end of the year.
Home Affairs Minister Datuk Seri Radzi Sheikh Ahmad said in a recent Cabinet decision, Rela had been given control of all such detention centres, which currently housed some 11,000 illegal immigrants.
Previously, these centres were run and managed by the staff from the Prisons Department, which came under the purview of the Internal Security Ministry.
"However, we will need about two years to train our own staff in running these immigration centres. So, for the time being, Rela members will be put in charge of these centres.- Star, 22/11/2007, Rela to take over immigration depots
Access to health care in detention centres is once every two weeks... for how many hours? Considering the number of detainees and their living condition, this is certainly far from adequate. There should be a permanent mini-clinic at every detention centre manned by a medical assistant, and a doctor at the very least. After all, there is already admission that it is indeed an environment that people can easily contract diseases.
