WORKER AND TRADE UNION RIGHTS MUST BE PRIORITIZED FOR THE WELLBEING OF THE WORKER
AND THEIR FAMILIES
We, the undersigned 47 civil
society organizations, trade unions and concerned groups, make the following
demands to better protect worker and trade union rights in Malaysia. It is sad
when a government places the interest of businesses, investors and employers
over the rights and welfare of workers and their families.
1. STABLE REGULAR EMPLOYMENT UNTIL RETIREMENT
AGE–ABOLISH PRECARIOUS SHORT-TERM EMPLOYMENT CONTRACTS
The right to permanent regular employment until retirement age is
essential for the economic wellbeing and financial stability of the worker and
their families.
A short-term or fixed term employment contract is a form of precarious
employment that must be abolished. It allows for the denial of the right of
retirement at 60, maternity rights and benefits, increments of rights which
comes with tenure, makes it near impossible for such workers to form, join or
even serve as leaders in existing unions. Such short-term employment contracts,
usually a year or less, with no right of extension even if the work still
exist, weakens worker capacity to struggle for better worker rights, and certainly
weakens unions or makes unionization impossible.
We call for guarantee of the right to regular employment until
retirement, and the abolition of short-term employment contracts and similar
precarious employment practices.
2.
ABOLISH THE ‘CONTRACTOR FOR LABOUR SYSTEM’ –
ENSURE DIRECT EMPLOYMENT RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN WORKER AND OWNER/OPERATOR OF
WORKPLACES
Direct employment relationship with the owner/operator of the workplace
known as the principal, is essential to ensure stable employment, noting that employers
do have the obligation to ensure worker rights and welfare are best protected.
A contractor for labour (COL) should never be employers, and their role, if any,
is to supply workers to owner/operators of workplace or alternatively find
workers work with employers who need workers, and for the service rendered they
should be paid a fee.
It is the owner/operator of workplaces, known as the principal, who
should be having direct employment relationship with workers that work at their
workplaces. This demand, amongst others, had been made vide the joint statement
by 93 groups dated 3/5/2012 entitled, ‘Abolish the ‘Contractor for Labour’
system - Withdraw the 2012 amendments to Employment Act 1955’, and also vide the earlier statement by 115
groups on 28/10/2011 entitled,‘Malaysia Must Protect Worker and Union
Rights, and withdraw proposed unjust amendments to Employment Act - Labour
Suppliers Should Not Be Employers’. We also draw attention to the Malaysian
Bar Resolution of 2012 expressing the same sentiment, which amongst others said
‘The Malaysian Bar takes the stand that labour suppliers and/or contractors of
labour should never be or continue to be employers of workers after they are
supplied, accepted and start working at the workplaces of principals or owners.
Thereafter, these workers shall be employees of the principal or owners of the
workplace.’ We also recall the MTUC initiated pickets and protests against the
‘contractor for labour system’.
3.
PREVENT OUTSOURCING OF WORK, ‘BREAKING UP OF
EMPLOYER COMPANIES’ AND OTHER SUCH SCHEME WHICH EFFECTIVELY DESTROYS WORKER
SOLIDARITY AND IS AN ACT OF UNION BUSTING.
To avoid trade unions and employer relationship, some employers are
outsourcing parts of the work to third party contractors who then use their own
employees to do the work. This happened in the plantation sector, and National
Union of Plantation Workers(NUPW), which once was a strong union with many
members, is today so much weakened even though the number of workers in the
plantation sector has remained the same or even increased. Another example, is
what happened to the banking sector when certain aspects of the banking
industry work like phone and internet banking was outsourced to third parties. Outsourcing
of work is yet another ‘union busting’ strategy, that weakens trade unions, and
deprives union members of the benefits of existing Collective Bargaining
Agreement.
Another method, is to break up one company into different smaller
companies, something that Tenaga Nasional Berhad(TNB) is now considering. This has
been strongly opposed by the 4 existing unions representing the many workers in
TNB. The break-up action would result in weakening of existing strong unions,
and possibly deprivation of existing members of benefits and rights they now
enjoy through Collective Bargaining Agreements. When new companies are formed,
workers who find themselves in these new entities would have to go through the
long process of forming, then getting union recognition all over again, and
entering into new CBA with their new employers, a process that can take years.
We support the statement of the 4 Trade Unions of TNB workers, being Persatuan Eksekutif
Tenaga Nasional Berhad (PETNB), Kesatuan Percantuman Pekerja-Pekerja TNB
(KPPPTNB), Tenaga Nasional Junior Officers Union (TNBJOU) and Persatuan Unit
Keselamatan TNB (PERUNIKA) dated 14/11/2013 opposing the proposal to break up
TNB.
4 STOP
THE TERMINATION AND PERSECUTION OF UNION AND WORKER LEADERS FOR ACTIVITIES TO
ADVANCE WORKER RIGHTS AND HIGHLIGHT INJUSTICES.
When the president of the National Union of Flight Attendants Malaysia (NUFAM)
issued a statement as Union President highlighting also some of the pending
issues yet to be dealt by Malaysian Airlines (MAS), he was terminated by reason
of issuing a statement as an employee. 53 organisations issued a statement on
3/3/2014 entitled, ‘Malaysian Airlines
Must Respect Trade Union and Worker Rights -Cease Anti-Union activities against
NUFAM and its members’, and we also refer to the earlier statement by 43
groups on 3/12/2013, entitled, ‘MAS Must
Immediately Revoke Suspension of Union President Ismail Nasaruddin Worker Right Issue Should Be Resolved By
Negotiations Not ‘Union Busting’.
Likewise, 18 workers were terminated by DRB HICOM for handing over a
Malaysian Trade Union Congress(MTUC) memorandum to candidates contesting in the
last General Election, where the object of MTUC was to get commitment from incoming
parliamentarians with regard to worker rights. We reiterate the statement by 51
groups issued on 25/6/2013 entitled, “DRB
HICOM Must Respect The Citizens’ Right To Participate In The Democratic Process
In Malaysia– Stop disciplinary action against workers for exercising their
political rights.”
Many other trade union leaders have been terminated for highlighting
injustices affecting workers, amongst others Abdul Jamil Lalaludeen and Chen
KaFatt who were, respectively, the Vice-President and the Honorary
Treasurer of the National Union of Bank Employees (NUBE); Hata Wahari, the President of the National Union of Journalists; Ismail
Nasaruddin, the President of NUFAM;
and Wan Noorulazhar , the
President of the Electronic Industry Employees Union Western Region, Peninsular
Malaysia (EIEUWR). We recall the Joint Statement by 87 groups dated 4/4/2013, ‘RENESAS
Must Immediately Accord Recognition To The Union And Reinstate Wan Noorulazhar.’
We call for the end of termination,
discrimination against and other forms of persecution against unionist and
worker leaders, all of which could be rightly perceived as union busting by bad
employers, which can be perceived as being condoned by Malaysian government.
We call for a repeal of the law that now
allows employers to terminate of unionist by simply treating it as an employee
misconduct. For example, NUFAM’s president was terminated because MAS said that
the act of an employee issuing a media statement was a misconduct.
5. RIGHT TO A DOMESTIC INQUIRY BEFORE BEING
TERMINATED
Ismail Nasarudin and 4 other from NUFAM were recently terminated without
even a Domestic Inquiry. In the spirit of industrial harmony and justice, when an
employer alleges a misconduct, natural justice demands that workers be accorded
the right to be heard and right to defend against the allegation in front an
independent panel.
In the case of the 18, who have been terminated by DRB HICOM
subsidiaries, they had a Domestic Inquiry but were denied the right to be
represented by a representative of their National Union. They were only allowed
to be represented by a worker from their own workplace.
Noting that the majority of workers are not even unionized, it is
essential that in the interest of justice, all workers shall have the right to
domestic inquiry, and this should be provided for in law. There must also be
the right accorded to the affected worker to be represented by a lawyer, unionist
or worker of their choice.
6. MISCONDUCT NEED TO BE STATUTORILY DEFINED
Employers have been arbitrarily increasing the number of misconducts,
many of which are vague and some even undermine fundamental rights of workers,
or their unions, including the right of workers to highlight injustices, fight
for better rights or even make representations to the relevant authorities to
complain about violation of rights.
In the case of the DRB HICOM, one of the alleged misconduct was the‘bringing
about or trying to bring about any form of influence or outside pressure to
submit or support any external claim that is related to service be it an
individual claim or claims of other employees’. Now, how can this be a
misconduct when it really is what workers and unions do – that is highlight and
campaign for support and hence ‘exertion of pressure’, etc… on employers, which
by the way is also the object of any worker pickets. It is absurd when this very
right is made into misconduct. 51 Groups issued a statement on25/6/2013, ‘DRB HICOM Must Respect The Citizens’
Right To Participate In The Democratic Process In Malaysia– Stop disciplinary
action against workers for exercising their political rights.’ Now, workers
in MAS are facing disciplinary actions for bringing their grievances to the
Ministry in Putrajaya.
Worker misconduct should never attempt to diminish worker rights,
freedom of expression, rights as citizens and other human rights.Like criminal
offences, misconducts must be clearly stipulated including also the penalties
that could be imposed by employer in the event the misconduct is proven or
admitted.
For the protection of workers, there must be laws that defining
employment misconducts, limiting it to matters at the workplace or reasonably
related, but never to prevent worker organizing, union building and union
activities. Attempts of employers to control the personal life, freedoms and
human rights of workers especially outside working hours should never be permitted.
7.
WHEN A WORKER TERMINATION HAS BEEN
DETERMINED AS BEING WITHOUT JUST CAUSE, THE RIGHT TO BE REINSTATED WITHOUT LOSS
OF BENEFITS MUST BE GUARANTEED.
When a worker is wrongfully dismissed, justice is sought by a worker
seeking reinstatement by lodging a complaint which ultimately goes to the
Industrial Court who decides whether it wasa wrongful dismissal or not. If wrongfully
dismissed, the employer shouldjustly be ordered to reinstate the worker without
loss of benefits.Alternatively, the worker should be able to claim compensation
in lieu of reinstatement.
In Malaysia, the choice between reinstatement and compensation is taken
away from the worker, and placed in the courts which now generally do not order
reinstatement. In 2007, a new Scheduled 2 was added to the Industrial Relations
Act 1977, which unjustly now not just limits the quantum of compensation in
lieu of reinstatement to not more than 24 months, and for probationers not more
than 12 months but also provides further deductions. This, rather than deter
employers from wrongfully dismissing workers now emboldens them to use
‘wrongful dismissal’ as a means to get rid of worker and/or union leaders. This
anti-worker Schedule 2 must be repealed, and the choice of accepting
reinstatement or compensation must be restored to the aggrieved worker.
8 PROBATION AND OTHER RIGHTS SHOULD BE PROTECTED BY THE
LAW FOR ALL WORKERS
More than 92% of workers in Malaysia are not unionized, and as such they
do not have the mechanism of a Collective Bargaining Agreement, that may allow the
recognition of basic worker rights now absent from labour legislations to be enjoyed.
Probation is one such right, which reasonably for a regular employee, should never
be more than three(3) months, being more than sufficient time for any employer
to assess the suitability of a worker to be considered and confirmed as a permanent
employee until retirement.
Now, many employers abuse this gap in the law, and keep workers as
probationers for very long periods sometimes even years, and this is because a
worker on probation has far less worker rights compared to a confirmed regular
employee. The law must now fix the maximum length of probation, and include a
deeming provision that after three(3) months, an employee shall be deemed to be
a confirmed employee.
9. EXPEDITE TRADE UNION REGISTRATION AND RECOGNITION
While time limits and consequences for failure to do something are there
in the law for acts to be done by workers and their unions, there is absence of
similar provisions when it comes to employers. The recognition of the trade
union in the case of RENESAS took about 4 years. In this case, there were times
that employer RENESAS failed to comply with explicit instructions by the
Ministry or was delay complying with the law, and this was possible when the
law provides no time limits or the consequence of an employer failing to do
something – this allows employers to so easily delay and even ignore workers
and trade union rights.
Recognition of trade unions, a condition that needs to be satisfied in
Malaysia before employers and trade unions are allowed to enter into Collective
Bargaining Agreement, must be expedited and dealt with speedily, preferably
taking no longer than three(3) months. The outcome of the ‘secret ballot’ must
just be based just on the number of votes cast, whereas now it unjustly
considers those who should have but did not manage to cast their votes as being
votes against the union.
The right to Judicial Review is acknowledged, but when employers resort
to using it to delay recognition of trade unions, it is essential that such
proceedings in courts are proceeded with speedily to prevent denial and
delaying worker and trade union rights. It is shameful how some employers are
willing to do whatever to deny workers their rights, Malaysian Airlines(MAS),
for example, is embarrassingly challenging the Minister’s decision to accord recognition
of NUFAM after the secret ballot conducted clearly showed that 62.73% flight attendants in MAS wanted NUFAM
as the union representing them.In the case of RENESAS, union recognition was
delayed for a year or more by reason of Judicial Review and appeals initiated
by the employer. As a matter of policy, such judicial review and appeals should
be speedily disposed as delays affects worker rights, and these court actions
should never be allowed to delay union recognition process, or the execution of
Collective Bargaining Agreements.
10. TRADE DISPUTES MUST BE RESOLVED
EXPEDITIOUSLY AND STATUS QUO PENDING RESOLUTION MUST BE MAINTAINED
History shows that it is strikes and industrial actions that have been
most effective means available to workers and their unions in resolving
disputes with employers and claiming rights, but Malaysia has interfered with
this option to the detriment of workers and unions, and have adopted a preference
of dealing with trade disputes vide negotiation and arbitration, and as such
this process must be done speedily, and workers and unionist must be
effectively protected from termination and discrimination by employers, more so
pending resolution of trade disputes or complaints.
The majority of the trade disputes are initiated by workers and unions,
who many a time have to suffer termination, discrimination or violation of
rights whilst employers continue their business operation as usual, and as such
justice demands that trade disputes be resolved speedily, not longer than 30 days,
and that any workers who have been terminated pursuant to the filing of or
related to a trade dispute should continuously be paid normal wages until the said
dispute is resolved. Employers should be barred from terminating workers or
unionists who have lodged trade disputes and/or complaints until the matter is
resolved.
11. MIGRANT WORKERS SHOULD NOT BE DISCRIMINATED
Equal pay for equal work is just. It is wrong for migrant workers to be
discriminated against with regards the right to minimum wages, as an example,
where the government is suggesting the making of migrant workers to now pay
levy, which was a payment imposed on employers to deter employers from
employing migrant workers over local workers. 82 groups issued a statement on
8/2/2013, ‘Minimum Wages For All
Workers, Including Migrant Workers - No to Wage Deduction to recover Levy
Payable By Employers –‘
12. THE UNILATERAL GIVING OF
EXEMPTION GRANTED TO EMPLOYERS TO EVADE RIGHTS PROVIDED BY LAW MUST STOP
The law provide for worker rights, but many a time there are provisions
that allow the Minister to provide exemption to certain employers. For example,
the maximum 8 hour working day or 48 hours working week,can also be avoided if
the employer gets an exemption. The exemptions are granted without the prior
knowledge of, let alone being accorded the right to be heard to, the affected
workers and/or their unions. There is the possibility to challenge the
exemptions within a limited time frame, but workers, especially those without
trade unions, just do not have the capacity to challenge such decisions.
Justly, the right to be heard and contest application for exemption must be
granted to the worker or their union, before the decision.In fact, employers
should never be granted exemptions, that will deny workers their worker or
trade union rights.
13. MINIMUM WAGES MUST BE SUFFICIENT TO SUSTAIN A DECENT
LIVELIHOOD
All workers in Malaysia are supposed to be receiving minimum wages as of
1 January 2014 but alas the quantum of minimum wages fixed in 2012 at RM900 for
Peninsular Malaysia, and RM800 for Sabah and Sarawak is no longer sufficient to
ensure a decent livelihood for the worker and his family given the large
increases in the cost of living. While for public sector workers get also Cost
of Living Allowances(COLA), the majority of the workers are in the private
sector do not get COLA. Using also the fact that the Malaysian government has
declared that households earning less than RM3,000-00 are in need of financial
assistance, it is only logical that minimum wages be increased for all workers
to at least RM1,500.
COLA should also be made a legal right for worker, especially for the
lower income worker. Minimum wage rates should also be reviewed at least every
6 months, taking into account the speedily increasing cost of living and the
monies required to ensure a decent livelihood for the worker and the family.
14. THE RIGHT TO UNEMPLOYMENT BENEFITS
In this day and age when employment is precarious, there is a need for
the government to put in place unemployment benefits to assist workers
temporarily out of a job and their families. Even if out of job, and deprived
of an income, regular payments for rental, basic amenities, car and house
loans, children’s education, etc is required of the unemployed worker. Without
financial assistance in the form of an unemployment benefit, the lives of the unemployed
worker and their families will be seriously affected. This safety net for workers
is something that is available in many countries, including also neighboring
Thailand.
15. NON-DISCRIMINATION BASED ON GENDER
While our Federal Constitution guarantees equality, courts have found
that the obligation not to discriminate workers based on gender is only on the
government and statutory bodies – not on private sector employers. This goes
against the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination
against Women (CEDAW) which Malaysia has ratified. The laws must be amended to
ensure that all employers do not discriminate workers based on gender or any other
forms of discrimination.
16. OCCUPATIONAL SAFETY AND HEALTH AT THE WORKPLACE
The Department of Occupational Safety and Health
(DOSH) recorded 1,248 workplace accidents in 10 sectors in the first five
months of 2013, which resulted in 68 worker deaths, 81 permanent disabilities
and 1,099 injuries not resulting in permanent disabilities.
In 2010, a total of 1426 cases of occupational
disease and poisoning have been reported to the Occupational Health Division as
compared with 791 cases reported in the previous year, whereby only about half
were successfully investigated. Amongst the diseases reported were noise
induced hearing loss (NIHL), occupational skin diseases and occupational lung
diseases. There is still a general low awareness about occupational diseases,
more so when it becomes evident long after the worker has left the workplace –
hence an under-reporting of occupational diseases occurs. For migrant workers
who have returned to country of origin, there yet no effective mechanism of
complaint or access to justice when it comes to occupational disease.
Malaysia must increase awareness of workers about
occupational disease, and be committed to active enforcement to ensure
occupational safety and health at the workplace. Hospitals and medical
practitioners should also inform workers with diseases or medical conditions
that could have been related to their workplace of this fact, and of where they
can lodge complaints and access justice.
Noting that many employers also provide workers
accommodation, there must be law stipulating the minimum standards of worker
housing that would protect the health and safety of workers. Migrant workers
who came into Malaysia with a clean bill of health have been subsequently sent
back by reason of diseases like tuberculosis(TB) that could have most likely
been contracted by reason of cramped worker housing or workplace, and as such
the list of occupational disease need to be reviewed to include also diseases
that could have been contracted by reason worker working or even poor worker housing
conditions.
17. WORKER RIGHTS IN LAW
FOR ALL WORKERS
Noting that in Malaysia, most workers are ignorant
of worker and trade union rights, a fact brought about also by reason that
worker and trade union rights are not taught in schools or colleges, it is thus
necessary that minimum worker rights are provided for and protected by law.The
laws that provide for minimum worker rights should ensure that these rights are
enjoyed by all workers, not just workers earning RM2,000 and below or just
certain classes of workers. Domestic workers, like all other workers, should also
have the right to enjoy all minimum worker rights provided for by law.
18. DO NOT SIGN AGREEMENTS THAT WILL ERODE OR
STAGNATE WORKER RIGHTS
Malaysia signs or will still sign Free Trade
Agreements and other Treaties, like the Trans-Pacific Partnership Agreement
(TPPA) without being open and transparent of the contents of the said
agreements, and without consultation with the people. Some of these agreements,
it is now known, contain clauses that will in effect not just erode but also
stagnate worker rights. One such clause is the Investor Protection Clause,
which protects investors allowing them to sue governments if the government
does anything in the future which would mean employers having to expend more
money, or do things that may affect the businesses profits. As such, if and
when Malaysia in the future decides to improve matters like worker rights,
worker safety, public health and environmental protection, requiring businesses
to thus expend monies which will impact profits, Malaysia risk being sued and
this may deter Malaysia from improving rights and working conditions of workers
in Malaysia.
It must be noted that in no way is the above a
comprehensive listing all demands or issues that affect worker and trade union
rights, but it is a listing of some of the fundamental issues and calls that
must be acted on, and not be allowed to swept aside with the lapse of time,
control of the media and other means.
The obligation to recognize and protect worker and
trade union rights is not just on the Malaysian government, but also on
business, corporations, employers, countries from where persons who own or
control businesses come from, countries from where the workers come from,
consumers of products and services provided, other businesses that have a link
with an employer by being within the supply chain or otherwise, and generally
everyone in our global community. It is an unacceptable attitude to say it is
alright to compromise on worker rights and standards as available in one’s
country or even businesses, for so long as one complies with the Malaysian law.
Ruggie’s"Guiding Principles on Business and
Human Rights: Implementing the United Nations 'Protect, Respect and Remedy'
Framework", is just but one of the standards and guidelines, that should
be adopted and followed by both governments, businesses and employers. It is
not just sufficient to ratify or sign United Nations(UN) or International
LabourOrganisation(ILO) Conventions and Instruments but not do the needful to
put into effect these commitments in Malaysia.
We call on
the Malaysian government to immediately act to ensure that all the above
demands are given effect to ensure justice for workers and trade unions in
Malaysia. The rights and welfare of workers and their families must be a
priority of any government, and this also include creating protection
mechanisms like unemployment benefits when workers are out of work.
We call for
the immediate reinstatement of all union and worker leaders including Abdul
Jamil Lalaludeen and Chen Ka Fatt from NUBE, Ismail Nasaruddin from NUFAM, Wan Noorulazharfrom EIUWR, and
RusainiMamat from NUTEAW.
We also call
for Malaysia to immediately ratify ILO Conventions 87, Freedom of Association
and Protection of the Right to Organise and Convention, and other important
worker conventions. We also call for Malaysia to give full effect to the ILO
and UN Conventions that it has ratified including also ILO Convention 98, Right
to Collective Bargaining.
Senator
Syed Shahir bin Syed Mohamud
Charles Hector
Mohd Roszeli bin Majid
Pranom Somwong
For and on behalf the 47
organisations listed below
Endorsements:-
ALIRAN
Asia Pacific Forum on Women , Law and Development (
APWLD)
Asian Muslim Action Network (AMAN) Indonesia
Center for Orang
Asli Concerns (COAC)
Clean Clothes Campaign
Club Employees Union
Peninsular Malaysia
CWI Malaysia (Committee For A Workers International
Malaysia)
Community Action Network(CAN)
Damn the Dams
Dignity International
Food Not Bombs-Kuala Lumpur
GoodElectronics Network
Human Rights Ambassador for Salem-News.com , UK
Jaringan Rakyat Tertindas (JERIT)
Kesatuan Eksekutif AIROD (KEA), Malaysia
Kesatuan Eksekutif Canon Opto
Kesatuan Pekerja-Pekerja
Polyplastics Asia Pacific (KPPAP)
Knowledge and Rights with Young people through Safer
Spaces (KRYSS)
MADPET(Malaysians Against Death Penalty and Torture)
MAP Foundation Thailand
National Union of Flight Attendants Malaysia
(NUFAM)
National Union of Hotel, Bar and Restaurant Workers (NUHBRW),
Malaysia
Network of Action for Migrants in Malaysia(NAMM)
Paper Products Manufacturing Employees’ Union of Malaysia
(PPMEU)
Parti Rakyat Malaysia(PRM)
Parti Sosialis Malaysia(PSM)
Pax Romana –ICMICA
Peoples ' Green Coalition,
Pergerakan Indonesia
Persatuan
Komuniti Prihatin Selangor dan KL (PRIHATIN)
Persatuan Sahabat Wanita Selangor
PINAY, Quebec, Canada
Pusat Komas
Radanar Ayar Rural Development Association
Sahabat Rakyat Working Committee
SALT (School of Acting Justly Loving Tenderly and Walking
Humbly)
Saya Anak Bangsa Malaysia (SABM)
Seksualiti Merdeka
Suara Rakyat Malaysia (SUARAM)
Tenaga Nasional Junior Officers Union (TNBJOU)
Tenaganita
Think Centre, Singapore
WH4C (Workers Hub For Change)
Workers Assistance Center, Inc. Philippines
Yayasan LINTAS NUSA - Batam – Indonesia
Youth
Section of The KL & Selangor Chinese Assembly Hall (Pemuda KLSCAH)
Bread for All, UK
No comments:
Post a Comment